The Truth About Nature Nate’s Honey: Heated, Not Raw, and High in HMF
Honey has been cherished for thousands of years, not just for its sweet taste but also for its numerous health benefits. However, not all honey is created equal. The quality and purity of honey can vary significantly depending on how it is processed. One brand that has come under scrutiny is Nature Nate’s Honey. Despite being marketed as “100% pure, raw, and unfiltered,” there are concerns about its production practices and the presence of potentially harmful compounds.
In this article, we will delve into the details of these concerns and explore why they matter, and why this a Honey to avoid.
What do these terms mean?
Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF): This compound forms when honey is heated. High levels of HMF can be toxic and potentially carcinogenic.
Health Benefits of Raw Honey: Raw honey is packed with nutrients, including all B-complex vitamins, vitamins A, C, D, E, and K, and minerals like magnesium, sulfur, phosphorus, iron, calcium, and potassium.
Heating Honey: Heating honey above 105 degrees Fahrenheit destroys most of its beneficial enzymes, amino acids, and phytonutrients. This is why beekeepers will often advise against pouring boiling water into Tea and Honey.
You can relate this process to how they’re treating modern Milk.
However, honey pasteurization shouldn’t be relative to Milk.
Which sounds like massive factory honey, not backyard bee honey.
Class Action Lawsuit: In March 2020, a class action lawsuit was filed against Nature Nate’s Honey for allegedly heating their honey and having high levels of HMF.
Adulteration Concerns: There were concerns about possible adulteration of Nature Nate’s Honey with added syrups, which is not expected in “100% pure and raw honey”.
The Misleading Branding of Nature Nate’s Honey
Nature Nate’s Honey is marketed as “100% pure, raw, and unfiltered.” This branding suggests that the honey is collected directly from the honeycombs of free-buzzing bees, strained to remove unwanted particles, and then bottled without any further processing.
However, testing of Nature Nate’s honey samples has shown that this is not the case. The honey has been heated to make it easier to process and flow, which contradicts the “raw” label.
Always check where it’s from. Product of BRAZIL and URUGUAY!
The Importance of Raw Honey
Raw honey is prized for its incredible health benefits. It contains all of the B-complex vitamins, vitamins A, C, D, E, and K, as well as minerals like magnesium, sulfur, phosphorus, iron, calcium, and potassium. Raw honey is also rich in live enzymes, amino acids, phytonutrients, and cancer-fighting antioxidants. These beneficial compounds are what make raw honey a superfood.
However, heating honey destroys most of these beneficial enzymes, amino acids, and phytonutrients. When honey is heated above 105 degrees Fahrenheit, it loses its raw status and many of its health benefits. This is why it is crucial to ensure that honey labeled as “raw” has not been subjected to high temperatures.
The Toxic Compound HMF
One of the most concerning findings in the testing of Nature Nate’s honey is the presence of high levels of hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF). I know, its a mouthful to try and pronounce.
HMF is a compound that forms when honey is heated. While small amounts of HMF are naturally present in honey, high levels can be toxic and potentially carcinogenic.
The Codex Alimentarius, a global reference standard for consumer protection, has determined that the maximum safe limit for HMF in raw honey is 40 mg/kg. However, samples of Nature Nate’s honey tested HMF values as high as 232 mg/kg.
These levels are not only far above the safe limit, but they also indicate that the honey has been heated up to 120 degrees.
Why is HMF toxic and potentially cancer causing?
Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) is a compound that forms when honey is heated. While small amounts of HMF are naturally present in honey, high levels can be toxic and potentially carcinogenic. Here are some reasons why HMF is considered harmful:
- Genotoxicity: HMF has been shown to induce genotoxic effects, which means it can damage genetic information within a cell, causing mutations that may lead to cancer. Studies have revealed that HMF may induce genotoxic and mutagenic effects in bacterial and human cells.
- Carcinogenicity: HMF can be converted in the body to 5-sulfoxymethylfurfural (SMF), a compound that has been shown to be genotoxic. Animal experiments have demonstrated that HMF can promote colon and liver cancer in rats and mice.
- Toxicity to Bees: High levels of HMF have been shown to be toxic to bees. Studies from the 1970s and 1980s found that feeding bees sugar syrup with HMF values of 150 mg/kg caused a mortality rate of 50% within 16 days. This suggests that high levels of HMF can be harmful to other living beings as well.
- Potential Health Risks: The presence of high levels of HMF in honey raises concerns about its safety for human consumption. While the exact impact on human health is still being studied, the potential for genotoxic and carcinogenic effects makes it a compound to be cautious about.
These factors highlight the importance of ensuring that honey is not heated to high temperatures, as this can lead to the formation of harmful levels of HMF. Choosing raw, unfiltered honey from reputable sources can help minimize the risk of exposure to this toxic compound.
The Class Action Lawsuit
In March 2020, a class action lawsuit was filed against Nature Nate’s Honey. The lawsuit alleged that the honey was heated and contained high levels of HMF, not “100% pure and raw.”
The lawsuit also raised concerns about possible adulteration of the honey with added syrups.
The court dismissed the case with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled. However, the dismissal was based on procedural grounds rather than the merits of the case. The concerns about the heating and adulteration of Nature Nate’s honey remain unresolved.
The Health Risks of High HMF Levels
High levels of HMF in honey are not just a concern for bees. Studies have shown that HMF can be toxic to humans as well.
Animal experiments have revealed that HMF may induce genotoxic and mutagenic effects in bacterial and human cells. HMF also promotes colon and liver cancer in rats and mice.
These findings suggest that consuming honey with high levels of HMF could pose serious health risks.
Adulteration Concerns
Another concern raised in the lawsuit was the possible adulteration of Nature Nate’s honey with added syrups. Adulteration can occur either by adding syrups directly to the honey or by feeding the bees heated sugar syrups. Both practices are harmful and compromise the quality and purity of the honey.
Consumers expect “100% pure and raw honey” to be free from any added syrups. The presence of syrups in Nature Nate’s honey raises questions about the company’s quality control and the integrity of its suppliers.
The Need for Transparency and Quality Control
To truly be called “100% pure, raw, and unfiltered,” Nature Nate’s Honey needs to eliminate the heating process and tighten its vetting standards for suppliers.
Transparency in production practices and rigorous quality control are essential to ensure that consumers are getting the high-quality honey they expect.
Finding Authentic Raw Honey
For those seeking the health benefits of raw honey, it is important to choose honey from reputable sources. Small beekeepers who produce honey from bees buzzing around healthy, biodiverse ecosystems are often the best choice.
These beekeepers prioritize the health of their bees and the purity of their honey, ensuring that it retains all its beneficial properties.
I recently wanted to bring attention back to this company once I saw they are now contributing to the Manuka Honey space. I mean, C’MON!
Conclusion
Nature Nate’s Honey has come under scrutiny for its misleading branding and questionable production practices. The presence of high levels of HMF and concerns about adulteration raise serious questions about the quality and purity of the honey.
Consumers deserve transparency and honesty from honey producers, and it is crucial to choose honey from reputable sources to ensure its health benefits.
If you are looking for truly raw honey, be sure to do your research and choose honey from small, reputable beekeepers who prioritize the health of their bees and the purity of their honey.
By doing so, you can enjoy the incredible health benefits of raw honey without the risks associated with heated and adulterated honey and better know which Honey to avoid.
-
Kirkland Signature Local Honey Pulled From Shelves
If you’re a Costco member, you may have noticed that the Kirkland Signature honey has been pulled temporarily. The honey is being re labeled to ensure that it isn’t misleading to it’s members. I reviewed Kirkland Signature twice, the Texas “Local” blend and the Southeast ” Local” blend. And what I found mirror’s Costco’s statement
-
Supermarket Honey Fraud: The 2011 “Honey Heist” & How to Spot Fakes
Is Your Supermarket Honey Real? The Truth Behind the 2011 “Honey Laundering” Scandal Have you ever looked at that golden bear in your pantry and wondered if it’s actually honey? For many Americans, the answer might be “not exactly.” Supermarket honey fraud is a deep problem in the Industry. Honey fraud, or “economically motivated adulteration,”
-
Manuka Honey
-
Texas Honey
